What Not to Wear to a Black Tie Event: 12 Mistakes Men Make

One-Button Tuxedo
Loading... 0 view(s)
What Not to Wear to a Black Tie Event: 12 Mistakes Men Make

The most common mistakes at a black tie event are wearing a black business suit in place of a tuxedo, swapping the bow tie for a long necktie, and wearing a tuxedo that does not fit. All three are easy to avoid, and none of them depends on spending more.

This article lists only what to avoid. If you want the complete outfit from jacket to socks, start with our black tie dress code checklist and come back here before you get dressed.

12 black tie mistakes and how to fix them

MistakeWhy it is wrongThe fix
1. Wearing a black suitA suit has plain lapels and no trouser stripe; next to tuxedos it looks like office wearWear a tuxedo with satin or grosgrain facings. If the code is "black tie optional," a dark suit is allowed
2. Long necktie in place of a bow tieBlack tie is named for the black bow tie; a necktie signals a different dress codeA black bow tie that matches the lapel facing
3. Colored or patterned bow tieIt turns a formal code into a costumeBlack, in silk, satin or grosgrain
4. Button-down or business shirtButton-down collars and visible plastic buttons belong with daywearA white tuxedo shirt, pleated or plain front, with a turndown or wing collar
5. A beltTraditional tuxedo trousers have no belt loops, and a buckle breaks the line at the waistTrousers that fit at the waist, held by side adjusters or braces
6. Brown, suede or rubber-soled shoesAnything other than black leather pulls the eye down and reads casualBlack patent or highly polished black oxfords
7. Showing shirt at the waistWhen the jacket is open, a strip of white shirt between trousers and jacket looks unfinishedKeep a single-breasted jacket buttoned when standing, or add a waistcoat or cummerbund
8. Jacket too bigExcess cloth at the shoulders and sleeves makes even a good tuxedo look rentedShoulders that end where yours do; about half an inch of shirt cuff showing
9. Trousers pooling on the shoeBunched fabric at the ankle spoils the stripe and the shoeA slight break or none; the hem just touches the top of the shoe
10. White or patterned socksThey flash every time you sit or cross your legsThin black socks long enough to cover the shin
11. A white dinner jacket in a cold city in winterWhite and ivory jackets are a warm-weather and resort traditionBlack or midnight blue in the cooler months; save white for summer and tropical venues
12. Bulging pocketsA phone, wallet and keys distort the cut of a fitted jacketCarry the essentials only, slim cardholder in the inside pocket, phone in the trouser pocket or left with a partner

The three that matter most

If you only remember three, remember these, because they are the ones guests notice across the room.

The suit swap

Many men assume a black suit and a black bow tie add up to black tie. They do not: the satin lapels and trouser stripe are what make a tuxedo a tuxedo, and the difference shows in every photo. If you are weighing the two, our guide to tuxedo vs suit lays out the details side by side.

The rental fit

A tuxedo that is a size too large in the shoulders is the most common giveaway of a rental. Shoulders cannot be fixed easily by an alterations tailor, which is why getting them right at the start matters more than any accessory. Every tuxedo in our tuxedo collection is made to order, in a standard size or to your own measurements, and our fit promise covers a free remake or up to $100 towards a local tailor if it does not fit.

The wrong code

Black tie and black tie optional are different invitations. Under "optional," a dark suit and long tie are acceptable; under "black tie," they are not. Read the invitation twice, and see our white tie vs black tie guide if the wording mentions white tie.

Smaller mistakes worth a second look

  • Fastening every button. On a two-button jacket, fasten only the top one. A one-button jacket is fastened when standing and opened when sitting.
  • An oversized sports watch. A slim watch on a leather strap, or none at all. Black tie is the one code where going without is traditional.
  • A puffed, colored pocket square. A white square in a straight fold is the classic choice. A white pocket square is all you need.
  • A creased shirt front. Pleated fronts need ironing pleat by pleat. Hang the shirt the night before, not on the morning.
  • Leaving it late. A made-to-measure tuxedo takes 2–3 weeks to make plus express shipping, so order at least a month ahead; a rush order is made in 7–10 days.

Questions

Can I wear a black suit to a black tie event?

Only if the invitation says black tie optional. For strict black tie, a suit is underdressed. If you have no time to get a tuxedo, a plain black suit with a white shirt and black bow tie is the least wrong substitute.

Is a pre-tied bow tie a mistake?

Not a serious one. A self-tied bow tie looks slightly more natural, but a good pre-tied one is far better than a long tie or a colored bow.

Can I wear loafers with a tuxedo?

Plain black leather loafers or velvet slippers are accepted by many hosts, especially at parties. For formal dinners and weddings, black oxfords are the safer choice.